Golden Age of Gaia

Toward a World that Works for Everyone

Menu
  • Home
    • About The Staff
    • FAQs
    • Glossary
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Downloads Page
    • Close
  • Contact Us
  • Commentary
    • Charlie
    • Kat
    • Kathleen Mary Willis
    • Narendra Mishra
    • Sitara
    • Steve Beckow
    • Suzanne Maresca
    • Writer’s Corner
    • Close
  • News
    • Ascension
    • Accountability
    • Building Nova Earth
    • Channelings/Commentary
    • Reval/GCR/Stewardship/Abundance
    • Homelessness
    • InLight Universal Shows
    • New Maps of Heaven
    • Opioid Crisis
    • Politics
    • Spirituality
    • Close
  • Library
  • Hope Chest
    • Hope Chest: Frequently Asked Questions
    • Close
  • Forums
  • Donate
/ Home / Commentary / Sitara / Stockton’s Basic-Income Experiment Pays Off
post

Stockton’s Basic-Income Experiment Pays Off

March 6, 2021 by Steve Beckow

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Thanks to Sitara.

Stockton’s Basic-Income Experiment Pays Off

A new study of the city’s program that sent cash to struggling individuals finds dramatic changes.

Annie Lowrey, The Atlantic, March 3, 2021

(https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/03/stocktons-basic-income-experiment-pays-off/618174/)

Two years ago, the city of Stockton, California, did something remarkable: It brought back welfare.

Using donated funds, the industrial city on the edge of the Bay Area tech economy launched a small demonstration program, sending payments of $500 a month to 125 randomly selected individuals living in neighborhoods with average incomes lower than the city median of $46,000 a year. The recipients were allowed to spend the money however they saw fit, and they were not obligated to complete any drug tests, interviews, means or asset tests, or work requirements. They just got the money, no strings attached.

These kinds of cash transfers are a common, highly effective method of poverty alleviation used all over the world, in low-income and high-income countries, in rural areas and cities, and particularly for households with children. But not in the United States. The U.S. spends less of its GDP on what are known as “family benefits” than any other country in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, save Turkey. The Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program spends less than one-fifth of its budget on direct cash aid, and its funding has been stuck at the same dollar amount since 1996—when the Clinton administration teamed up with congressional Republicans to turn it into a compulsory-work program. Those changes sliced into the safety net, allowing millions of people to fall through.

Most adults without children have no program to help them keep gas in the car and a roof over their head, no matter how poor they are. Most families with kids don’t have one either. In the United States, poverty is used as a cudgel to get people to work. We got rid of welfare for poor families’ and poor individuals’ own good, the argument goes. Give people money, and they stop working. They become dependent on welfare. They never sort out the problems in their life. The best route out of poverty is a hand up, not a handout.

Stockton has now proved this false. An exclusive new analysis of data from the demonstration project shows that a lack of resources is its own miserable trap. The best way to get people out of poverty is just to get them out of poverty; the best way to offer families more resources is just to offer them more resources.

The researchers Stacia Martin-West of the University of Tennessee and Amy Castro Baker of the University of Pennsylvania collected and analyzed data from individuals who received $500 a month and from individuals who did not. Some of their findings are obvious. The cash transfer reduced income volatility, for one: Households getting the cash saw their month-to-month earnings fluctuate 46 percent, versus the control group’s 68 percent. The families receiving the $500 a month tended to spend the money on essentials, including food, home goods, utilities, and gas. (Less than 1 percent went to cigarettes and alcohol.) The cash also doubled the households’ capacity to pay unexpected bills, and allowed recipient families to pay down their debts. Individuals getting the cash were also better able to help their families and friends, providing financial stability to the broader community.

“It let me pay off some credit cards that I had been living off of, because my household income wasn’t large enough,” one recipient named Laura Kidd-Plummer told me. “It helped me to be able to take care of my groceries without having to run to the food bank three times a month. That was very helpful.” During the study, Laura also experienced a spell of homelessness when the apartment building she was living in had a fire. The Stockton cash helped her secure a new apartment, ensuring that she could afford movers and a security deposit.

The researchers also found that the guaranteed income did not dissuade participants from working—adding to a large body of evidence showing that cash benefits do not dramatically shrink the labor force and in some cases help people work by giving them the stability they need to find and take a new job. In the Stockton study, the share of participants with a full-time job rose 12 percentage points, versus five percentage points in the control group. In an interview, Martin-West and Castro Baker suggested that the money created capacity for goal setting, risk taking, and personal investment.

“The big change was how it helped me see myself,” Tomas Vargas, another recipient, told me. “It was dead positive: I am an entrepreneur, I think of business ideas, I make business choices, I want to be financially stable.” When the program started, he worked in logistics. Now, in addition to nurturing his side projects, he is a case manager for individuals on parole.

Zach Parolin: Welfare money is paying for a lot of things besides welfare

He noted that receiving the money had made him more civically and politically engaged, if also more infuriated at the country’s scorn toward low-income households. “It’s like it’s a big game,” he said. “These people are living with a silver spoon, talking—but how about you walk this life? Have you ever even seen it?”

Finally, the cash recipients were healthier, happier, and less anxious than their counterparts in the control group. “Cash is a better way to cure some forms of depression and anxiety than Prozac,” says Michael Tubbs, a former mayor of Stockton, who spearheaded the project. “So many of the illnesses we see in our community are a result of toxic stress and elevated cortisol levels and anxiety, directly attributed to income volatility and not having enough to cover your basic necessities. That’s true in the public-health crisis we’re in now.”

More work, less destitution, more family stability, less strained social networks, less stress, fewer incidences of homelessness, fewer skipped meals: This is what welfare could give the country.

And it just might. America’s welfare politics have shifted radically of late, in part because of the economic pressures felt by Millennials, the first generation in recent U.S. history likely to end up poorer than their parents. Two once-in-a-lifetime recessions, persistent wage stagnation, wild wealth and income inequality, the student-debt crisis, housing shortages, and a broader cost-of-living crisis have made redistributive policies much more palatable to them—and they’re now the country’s largest voting bloc. The pandemic has shifted U.S. welfare politics too, emphasizing the need for child-care benefits and demonstrating the power of cash as stimulus.

Right now, Democrats are pushing to send low- and middle-income parents $300 a month for each child younger than 6 and $250 a month for children ages 6 to 18 as part of President Joe Biden’s $1.9 trillion coronavirus-relief package. The program would be temporary, but there is wide support for making it a permanent entitlement. Senator Mitt Romney, a Utah Republican, has put forward a proposal to eliminate TANF and replace it with a straightforward child allowance. A number of state, local, and nonprofit efforts are getting going too.

The Stockton demonstration project is ending. But a group Tubbs founded, called Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, is extending the initiative nationwide, with cities from Compton to Gary to Newark making plans to send low-income residents cash.

These policies are being described as child allowances, guaranteed incomes, and universal basic incomes—not as welfare—thus dropping some of the racist freight attached to TANF. But they are, in fact, a kind of welfare. Both as a policy and a concept, it is what so many Americans need.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Email

Filed Under: Sitara, Steve Beckow, Universal Basic Income

Subscribe to the Golden Age of Gaia

Recent Posts

  • The Time to Do the Work is Now
  • The Making of a Retreat Centre
  • Divine Mother: Instantaneous Transmission Spreading Like a Virus
  • Zoom Recording: Law of Unification, Unity, Part 4
  • Nicky Hamid: Remember
  • The 9D Arcturian Council Through Daniel Scranton: How to Safely Channel Higher-Frequency Energies
  • Ahanryia, Dragon Speaks
  • Archangel Gabriel through Shelley Young ~ Analogy for the Spiritual Journey
  • SG Anon File #37, January 26, 2023
  • Mike Quinsey’s Higher Self Message, Jan. 27, 2023

Archives

Collective Meditation: Sending LOVE Tuesdays — 5-5:30pm PST / 8-8:30pm EST

Holding Love and Sending Love

Click on Graphic

What is G/NESARA?

Digger: Address to Councils

A New Society Based on Transparency…

Jesus: You are Bringing to Light What Needs to be Revealed

  • You live in tumultuous times and you live in a time of fulfilment. … You are leaving compassion and latitude for correction and understanding.
  • You are bringing to light what needs to be revealed so it doesn’t destroy the fiber of your society. …
 When you see the shadow, it defines the light.  (Jesus through Linda Dillon, Heart Call, Sept. 19, 2020.)

The End of the End: Straight Talk from Riccardo Bosi

Hit graphic to watch video

Ezra Cohen-Watnick: Spelling It Out 1 Time

Program Guide to Tonight’s Performance by Juan O Savin

French General Pays Tribute to AntiVaxxers

Archbishop Vigano Calls for Anti-Globalist Alliance

Matthew Ward on Virus, Vaccine, and 5G

Who are the Illuminati?

Matthew Ward answers.

9D Arcturian Council: Our Mission, Your Purpose & Source’s Desire

An Open Letter to the Unvaccinated

Russell L. Blaylock: Covid Update: What is the Truth?

Dr. Peter McCullough: Let’s Win the War Against Therapeutic Nihilism

1969 Doctors and Health Professionals: End all CV19 Measures

Excess Deaths Due to Covid

Graphene Hydroxide and the Transhumanist Agenda

https://goldenageofgaia.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/LEAKED-22Project-Pandora22-Multiple-Presidents-KILLED-to-Keep-this-HIDDEN.mp4

Declaration of the People of the United States for Global Peace and Prosperity

To Support and Defend: Civil/Military Relations

 

2000 Mules

“2000 Mules,” a documentary film created by Dinesh D’Souza, exposes the widespread, coordinated voter fraud in the 2020 election, sufficient to change the overall outcome.

Election Fraud Explained

  • Mike Lindell’s Absolute Proof of election fraud

9/11 – What Really Happened on That Day?

The Question of Sending Love and Light


Can sending love and light be harmful?

Reassurance for Those Who Feel Disturbed by the Cabal’s Plan

rabbit-hole

How Do I Make Sense of Our World?

The best introduction to the subject in recent memory.

There is a Plan

There will be no world war. No nuclear devices can be exploded in space. Global martial law is to restore law and order worldwide. There is a Plan.

Spiritual Advice in Troubled Times

  • The Arcturian Group explains….

9D Arcturian Council: True in All Realities

Canadian Freedom Convoy 1

https://goldenageofgaia.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Cities-across-Canada-join-the-movement-1.mp4

Canadian Freedom Convoy 2

https://goldenageofgaia.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/telegram-cloud-document-1-4915997293301204030-1-1.mp4

Please support this site. Donate:


A 501(c)(3) tax-exempt non-profit
  • Building, anchoring, and restoring hope, trust and Love within the human community.
  • "The key to Love is sharing, ... [balancing] give and receive." - The Divine Mother.

Downloads Page

(Always) free introductory texts on Ascension, Disclosure, Abundance, and Accountability. Especially of interest to those new to these subjects.

Kathleen: A Door to Everything/Voice of Freedom

  • Welcome to my two websites, A Door to Everything and Voice of Freedom, the first about volunteering with women in recovery and the second about how things work in the higher realms.
  • I offer Online Card Readings, Zoom Meditation and Classes on How Things Work in the Higher Realms, Tuesdays, Wednesdays, & Fridays. See GAoG or VoF for class links.

For your daily news, join Suzi on Buy Me a Coffee!

 

  • Dynamic times and rampant internet censorship brought me to create a new outlet for the unending flow of information.
  • Information is Light. Seeking information is Light Work.
  • My news site link ~ https://www.buymeacoffee.com/SuzanneMaresca.

Spiritual Counselling

  • Releasing old patterns of limitation.
  • Remembering, embodying, and expressing your true Self

Len Satov
SourceLight – Seeing you home
http://www.lensatov.com/

HB & AHWAA Transcripts & Audios: Divine Beings, Universal Laws, Blessings & Virtues

* HB/AHWAA Transcripts and Audiotapes

* On the Importance of the Universal Laws

* The Universal Law: What, How, and Why?

Lightworker Links


Our recommendations on other lightworker sites.

Alternative News of the World

Our recommendations on other constructive news sites.

What is the Purpose of Life?


Click on graphic

All of life is embarked on the same journey – from God to God – a voyage of Self-discovery

The Mother’s Clarion Call to All of Humanity!

This is my clarion call to all of humanity to embrace love, to embrace truth, to embrace peace…

The Divine Mother’s Mandate

Build what is divinely beautiful. I give you my divine authority to do so. I will guide you. I will help you. But I entrust this to you as well. …

  • We are helping you. That gateway is open and you are being flooded and you are being assisted and you will be assisted every step of the way.
  • – “Transcript ~ The Divine Mother: Take Up Your Divine Authority, AHWAA, February 23, 2017,” February 28, 2017.
  • On the Divine Plan for Ascension.

The Pattern of the Mother

  • This universe is designed around the pattern of the Divine Mother. What is that pattern?
  • Creation, preservation, transformation = love building, love preserving, love dissolving = inbreath, pause, outbreath = rajas, sattwa, thamas (gunas) = Akar, Ukar, Makar (Aum) = Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva (Trimurthy).

Archangel Michael: Lead or Leave a Vacuum


If no [lightworker] steps forward into [leadership] ...

Archangel Michael: Do not Get Caught in the Drama of White Hats or Black Hats

  • Beloved ones, do not allow yourselves to be distracted, yes, by the chaos….
  • Do not get caught in the drama of white hats or black hats, or good guys or bad guys. All beings are birthed directly from the Heart of One…. (“Archangel Michael: Do not Get Caught in the Drama of White Hats or Black Hats,” Nov. 12, 2019; see here.

Do not Venture Where There is No Love

Do not venture where there is no love. Because, if there is no love, then there is no truth. And if there is no truth, there will not be peace and [peace], Sweet One, is the Plan. (Archangel Michael, Personal Reading, June 17, 2020.)

Ronna Vezane ~ Archangel Michael’s Gift: New Age Creed

Werner Erhard on Responsibility

“Responsibility begins with the willingness to take the stand that one is cause in the matter of one’s life. It is a declaration not an assertion, that is, it is a context from which one chooses to live. Responsibility is not burden, fault, praise, blame, credit, shame or guilt. In responsibility, there is no….”  (Read more…)

Arcturian Sacred Geometry

Mission Statement of the Golden Age of Gaia

On a Personal Note

  • I’m neither qualified to be a spiritual teacher nor do I wish to be one.
  • I’m a writer who wishes to share his views with you on subjects of mutual interest and listen to yours as lightworker equals and spiritual adults.

Copyright © 2023 The Golden Age Of Gaia

Copyright © 2023 · Dynamik-Gen on